How to Save Chicago


The title raises the obvious question: Does Chicago need saving?

I guess the answer is clear. Aaron Renn published a reviewofthe 2010 census, and for Chicago it was not pretty. Since 2000 the city lost over 200,000 people: nearly 7.5% of its Black residents, and almost 6% on non-Hispanic Whites. Only the Hispanic population grew, but at an anemic 3.4%. Even the metro area writ large isn’t doing all that well, growing by only 3.9% (against the nation’s 10%).

Los Angeles, described as “a city in secular decline" appealed to the schadenfreude in my heart. As a Chicago booster, the decline of an arch-rival is emotionally (if irrationally) satisfying. But sadly, many of LA’s problems are Chicago’s issues as well: a decline of the central business district, an exodus of major businesses, the disproportionate influence of real estate on local politics, and ethnic politics. Add to that a still vibrant Outfit (mob), a lousy climate, and apart from Lake Michigan, little in the way of natural distinction, and you don’t have a pretty picture.

Even some gentrification seems to be wearing thin. Walking along Clark St. there are plenty of empty store fronts. It’s beginning to look a little dreary (though still far from a slum).

That all sounds pretty desperate. But there is some good news as well.

  • My wife and I inadvertently got off the Skyway one exit too soon and wound up driving down 87th St. to Stony Island. This is a thriving, middle-class Black neighborhood. Every storefront was occupied, and there was no graffiti! (Unlike graffiti-scarred Rome, which we also recently visited.)
  • Public transport is alive and well in Chicago. Trains and buses are clean, graffiti-free, and the passengers are civilized.
  • There is lots of affordable housing. Plenty of “luxury apartments” are for rent along Clark St. One can buy a perfectly nice condo for $100K or less. Many neighborhoods have been redeveloped and are really nice; Logan Square is a good example. This is the good side of the real estate bust, and gives the city a huge advantage over, say, New York or San Francisco.
  • Lakeshore Drive, Michigan Avenue, Wacker Drive, and even State Street are as fabulous as ever, especially in nice weather.

So there is hope, but the patient is sick, and if things don’t change then Chicago could go the way of St. Louis or Detroit.

So how can Chicago be saved? Here is my advice to Rahm Emanuel, the new Mayor.

  • Forget about the old business model – the world has changed. The days of small-time manufacturing or major banking centers are over. The notion that The Loop is going to be the home of large corporations is past. So concentrate on the new world: what can Chicago do well? I count three things: Residential, Retail, and Tourism. And Chicago has (quite inadvertently) done the residential part right. It’s the other stuff that needs attention.
  • Remember why Sears Roebuck started in Chicago: it was the center of the country. The Windy City is still is the center of the country. It should have the World’s Busiest Airport. It still is the railroad capital of America. It could be the retail capital of America. Chicago – The Loop, Michigan Avenue, Woodfield Mall, all of it – can be where America comes to shop. If relative pipsqueak Minneapolis can make a success of the Mall of America, just think what Chicago can do.
  • So – first step – lower sales taxes! We paid over 10% tax at a restaurant on Rush St. That’s crazy! Reduce sales taxes to 4% (or eliminate them entirely). Perhaps this will mean a decline in government revenue, but so what? It will create thousands of jobs and billions in business. (If politicians were really interested in their constituents rather than their own perks, this would be a no-brainer.)
  • Maintain the neighborhoods. I know the stockyards are long gone, but where is that really good steakhouse in Bridgeport? Likewise, I’m happy to drive to 87th and Stony Island for dinner and good music, but you need to ensure my safety. The city doesn’t need more real estate - it needs more cops, public transit, art, advertising, and street lights.
  • Free parking on Sundays. I know the city has taken a lot of flak for parking, but in principle it works. I parked within a couple of blocks of a fancy restaurant on Rush St. on a Friday night ($6). I parked within a block of Clark & Diversey so my wife could go shopping ($2). Before the new meters I would have had to drive around for an hour to find a place to park, and then it’d be many blocks away. Now it’s easy, and (compared to wasting time and gas) not expensive.

But free parking on Sundays would bring them in from the suburbs in droves! New York does that, and that’s the only day we drive down to the City. Cut folks a break – it’s good business.

  • Improve public transit. That doesn’t mean new trains, but it does mean more safety. Let me take the train to Chinatown at night and have it be an enjoyable experience. Where is the convenient bus to Hyde Park? Why can’t I buy a tourist day-pass or a weekend pass for the CTA at my local station? And why do the ticket vending machines not accept credit cards? Oh, and if you do have an extra train or two, why not run A and B express trains on the Red Line? They did that 25 years ago.
  • Keep the cows. I don’t mean the stockyards, I mean the art. Of course the actual street-corner cows are passe, but Marilyn Monroe isn’t – she works. Use your architecture, your waterfront, your grand vistas. Use your imagination.

Here is the key:  for Mayor Emanuel and for all politicians. The citizens have to earn money before you can tax it. Exorbitant sales taxes just spoil it for everybody. Yes, I know you need to spend money on schools and welfare and public-employee pensions. But you can’t do that if the money isn’t there in the first place.

So get Chicago open for business. Lower sales taxes. Ensure public safety downtown and in the neighborhoods. Invest a little in mass transit. Give up just a bit of the parking revenue. Chicago is a great tourist and shopping destination, better than Rome in every way except ruins. Allow your citizens to cash in before Chicago itself becomes a ruin.

Daniel Jelski is Dean of Science & Engineering State University of New York at New Paltz.

Photo by smik67.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Keep up the good work

This article has some great and useful information about this subject. Thank you for sharing it in an easy to read and understandable format. About us

The title raises the

The title raises the obvious question: Does Chicago need saving?
I guess the answer is clear. Aaron Renn published a reviewofthe 2010 census, and for Chicago it was not pretty. manga comic Since 2000 the city lost over 200,000 people: nearly 7.5% of its Black residents, and almost 6% on non-Hispanic Whites. Only the Hispanic population grew, but at an anemic 3.4%. Even the metro area writ large isn’t doing all that well, Chihayafuru 2 watch online growing by only 3.9% (against the nation’s 10%).
Los Angeles, described as “a

However, new roads must also

However, new roads must also be built with the goal of equitably distributing our nation's resources among our nation's people. Infrastructure choices have an impact on the lives of real people, not just economic growth numbers on a spreadsheet. Social inequity creates massive inefficiencies in elance freelancing the economy and ultimately results in sluggish growth and higher costs for all. Though you cite the example of gentrification in some parts of Washington, Washington is in reality a much larger city than the core area.

Nice view and point

I really appreciate the believed that you put into this content. This subject has been something I have been looking into for a few time and your publish is one of the best I have study.


It's one of my hobbies to ride transit in strange cities. CTA is easy to use, but doesn't go that many places; and it is not well coordinated with METRA, the other system. I suppose I could look up on the Internet and see how often METRA runs. In Germany, all the systems of a city - the S-Bahn, the U-Bahn, and the national rail - are mapped together. And only METRA offers convenient access to Hyde Park, Obama's city, as well as to most of the outer suburbs to the west and south. I have not figured out how to use it.

Using the train is one of

Using the train is one of the most efficient ways to travel around Chicago. I'm from a small town and when I visited Chicago I was in shock at how people would drive their car. Retractable Banners

This article has some great and useful

I admire the precious information you offer in your articles. I'll bookmark your blog and have my children check up here often. We are quite sure the can learn several new stuff here than anybody else!
gambling addiction and debt

I've often heard tourists

I've often heard tourists complaining about not having cash on them to pay for the trains. What a joke! They must actually be losing money! Is it really that hard to process credit cards? I think not, Chicago!

Saving American Cities from Shameless Corporate Hacks

Joel Kotkin isn't interested in understanding anything. He is a ideological hacks you wants the suburban/highway/ real estate/finance/collatrolized debt obligations/styrofoam house industrial complex that has almost ruined us to continue forever, no matter what businesses or anyone else wants in chicago or anywhere else. Joel Kotkin is a shameless attach dog for these interests with the thinnist veneer of intellectualism. Don't be fooled. Kotkin makes conclusions first and finds facts latter. Rest assured that he needs you much more that you need any of his propaganda. He is a kind of tv preacher for suburbia, minus the hair and the tax deductability.