Rahm Emanuel’s Chicago More Violent than Al Capone’s Chicago and the Old West

Since Rahm Emanuel entered the political scene years ago, he’s been a master at manipulating the press to his benefit. A pliant media has largely gone along with whatever talking point Emanuel desired. Lately, some of the media has begun to put the spotlight on violent Chicago with its rather high murder rate. Banning or restricting handguns has not been very successful in combatting violence in Chicago.  The website Big Government reports the bloody details:

After Chicago recorded a terrible homicide total of 53 in August, September wasn't much better for Rahm's "world class" city. The city suffered 41 homicides, 30 of which resulted from 184 total shootings

September brings more bad news for Chicago residents. While Mayor Rahm Emanuel, Police Superintendent Garry McCarthy, and the Chicago media have continued to hammer the point that the "crime rate is down," and "murder is down," as of September 22, the homicide total for 2013 now exceeds the rate up to the same date in 2011 by two percent at 350, according to the Chicago Police Crime Data Portal.

How does today’s Chicago hold up at the violent memory of Al Capone’s Chicago of the 1920s? Not very well.  WLS-TV investigated the data and the evidence is rather stunning report in February:

Let's compare two months: January 1929, leading up to the St. Valentine's Day Massacre, and last month, January 2013. Forty-two people were killed in Chicago last month, the most in January since 2002, and far worse than the city's most notorious crime era at the end of the Roaring Twenties.

Even though the image of Chicago, perpetuated by Hollywood over the years, was that mobsters routinely mowed down people on the streets, the crime stats tell us that we were safer under Capone than Emmanuel. In January 1929 there were 26 killings. Forty-two people were killed in Chicago last month, the most in January since 2002.

Even though the image of Chicago, perpetuated by Hollywood over the years, was that mobsters routinely mowed down people on the streets, the crime stats tell a different story. The figures from January 2013 are significantly higher than the January of Al Capone's most famous year.

It’s not just the Capone era violence that doesn’t hold up to scrutiny. Constantly we hear from the media and advocates of gun control that we don’t want things to become “the Wild West”. In the last several years, historians have begun to look at this long time legend that was promoted by Hollywood movies.  As Ryan McMaken explains:

Historian Richard Shenkman largely attributes this to the legacy of those reliably-violent Western films. "Many more people have died in Hollywood Westerns than ever died on the real Frontier…[i]n the real Dodge City, for example, there were just five killings in 1878, the most homicidal year in the little town's Frontier history: scarcely enough to sustain a typical two-hour movie."

The old West with its minimal government and armed populace has never been too popular with progressives. But, the reality is it was never really violent according to Terry Anderson and Peter Hill. So, the murder rate of the Capone era and Dodge city of 1878 would be a major improvement for Mayor Rahm Emanuel.

Note: This post was originally incorrectly attributed to Wendell Cox.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Thanks for taking this

Thanks for taking this opportunity to read this article, I'd like to learn about this subject.
sơ mi nam
giầy lười nam
samsung galaxy a3
jean nam
giầy thể thao

Even though the image of

Even though the image of Chicago, perpetuated by Hollywood over the years, was that mobsters routinely mowed down people on the streets, the crime stats tell us that we were safer under Capone than Emmanuel. holster reviews

I really impressed the way

I really impressed the way you described the topic. Fantastic page with lot of information. I will bookmark it for future reading. Copper Bare Wire || Selenium Training Course || Circular Connectors Manufacturers || Water Coolers Dealer || Custom Peptide Synthesis || Fine Finish Spray Equipment

This is a very good and

This is a very good and informative post. This post has helped a lot of people out there. But I am the only one who'll appreciate it. Thanks!
Copper Wire || Business Analyst Training || AC Maintenance Contract || Peptides Manufacturer || Painting Pump || Circular Military Connectors

dich vu thanh lap doanh

dich vu thanh lap doanh nghiep
Intelligent Exposure rig Part III of the Circular 60/2006/TT members - BTC and council approval . Without adequate standard conditions known to be contributing members to become useful members of the company or repayment prescribed by law . State disaster
dich vu thanh lap cong ty

giàn phơi thông minh dich

giàn phơi thông minh
dich vu establish enterprises Two Case in which members of the deceased or the Court declared dead , then the heirs by will or under the laws of the member companies help the members .
bang tai

Seriously? This story is

Seriously? This story is still near the top of this blog....and long after new stats show that 2012 really was an anomaly and that Chicago, like other major cities is back to mid 1960's crime figures. Just more Chicago bashing with barely hidden political undertones.

Seriously? Seriously

This is a seriously stupid piece of commentary – among the stupidest I've read in some time. And I'm not saying that as an ad hominem attack. As earlier commentators point out, the article's idiotic politics on guns aside, comparing 1920s Chicago to the Chicago of today is about as severe a case of apples and oranges that exists. We might as well compare modern-day Detroit and St. Louis and Philadelphia to their early 20th-century incarnations...without admitting any of the changes that have occurred in those metro areas either.

I urge everyone to check out Mason Johnson's commentary on the city's gun violence – it's an extremely erudite, extremely HONEST look at the issue: http://chicago.cbslocal.com/2013/09/26/chicago-not-actually-murder-capit....

apples and Garry McCarthy

That's what the superintendent does when he goes around selling the lie on WGN and Chicago Tonight about Chicago's "historic" drops in crime to "historic lows."
He keeps wanting to dupe with the idea that it's o.k to compare crime from today's 2.7 million population to crime rates from the 60's when Chicago's pop. topped 3 mil. without accounting for the depopulation, or any of the other factors that make it a false comparison.

Chicago Crime Now and in Al Capone's day

Sir: In 1920 Chicago constituted approximately 42% of total Illinois population, including most of people the higher income segments. Today, Chicago constitutes about 22% of the state's population and many of the middle and upper class neighborhoods are now filled with lower income residents. It makes NO SENSE to compare Chicago City from 1920 to today. Comparing Chicago Metro does make sense because it reflects the full demographic complement of a complete American city.

I'm surprised that this of all blogs would make such a Freshman mistake.

Automatic D.