Moving to Flyover Country

iStock_000006811038XSmall.jpg

As the international financial crisis and the US economy have worsened, there have been various reports about more people “staying put,” not moving from one part of the country to another. There is some truth in this, but the latest US Bureau of the Census estimates indicate the people are still moving, and in big numbers.

In the year ended June 30, 2008, 670,000 people moved between states. This is down substantially from the peak years of 2005 to 2007, when housing prices in California and its suburbs of Nevada and Arizona, Florida, the Northeast and the Northwest reached record heights never seen before. In those years, people could elicit considerable and unprecedented financial gain by moving to parts of the country where the housing bubble had not visited or had done less damage. A household could buy in Indianapolis, Dallas-Fort Worth or Atlanta and save more than $1,000,000 in purchase price and mortgage payments compared to a comparable house in San Diego, Los Angeles or the San Francisco Bay area. In 2006, net domestic migration between states peaked at 1,200,000.

Still, despite the reduction from the most extreme bubble years, last year’s interstate migration numbers still exceeded those of 2001, 2002 and 2003 and nearly equaled 2004. Lost in the discussions of the decline has been the continuation of a seemingly inexorable secular trend: the continued migration to the “Flyover County” that many of the coastal urban elites tend to dismiss as insignificant and even unlivable. What residents of Elitia reject, millions are embracing.

Can 3,500,000 Movers be Wrong? The new data shows a strong trend of domestic migration to Flyover Country. Between 2000 and 2008, 3,500,000 residents moved to Flyover Country. This is roughly equal to the movement of the entire population of the City of Los Angeles. Moreover, the trend has been accelerating. In the last four years, the number of people relative to the population leaving Elitia’s promised lands has increased by 60 percent.

The Lost Empire: New York has lost residents at a rate exceeding that of any other state or the District of Columbia. Not even the destructive winds of Katrina and Rita, the malfeasance of the Army Corps of Engineers or even mis-governance – from Washington to Baton Rouge and New Orleans itself – could drive people out as effectively as the Empire State. New York has lost 1,575,000 domestic migrants since 2000, nearly equal to the population of Manhattan.

New York’s net domestic migration loss is equal to 8.1 percent of its 2000 population, compared to Louisiana’s 7.1 percent loss. New York has even outdone that perpetual exporter of residents, the District of Columbia, which lost a mere 7.6 percent through domestic migration.

From Golden State to Fool’s Gold State: Then there is California, which has added more people over the past 50 years than live in Australia. How things have changed. Early in the decade, the Golden State was suffering somewhat modest domestic migration losses. But by 2005, with house prices escalating wildly relative to incomes, California won the race to the bottom. Each year since then, California has driven away more people than any other state.

What’s Right with Pennsylvania: There are anomalies, however. One of the leading parlor games is “what’s wrong with Pennsylvania” stories. From the Philadelphia Inquirer to Washington’s Brookings Institution, there has probably been more hand wringing about Pennsylvania than about all other states combined. Yet things have changed materially, and largely for the better. Although Pennsylvania continues to lose domestic migrants, the rate has been far less than elsewhere in the Northeast. Between 2000 and 2008, Pennsylvania lost less than 50,000 domestic migrants. Its neighboring states – New York, New Jersey, Maryland and Ohio (Delaware and West Virginia have had small gains) – have lost more than 2,300,000 domestic migrants or nearly 50 domestic migrants for every one leaving Pennsylvania. Among states with more than 10,000,000 population, only Florida and Texas have done better in domestic migration than Pennsylvania.

That’s pretty good company for a state so many have declared to be on life support. Indeed, it is time to ask “what’s right about Pennsylvania?” One answer might be that Pennsylvania home prices did not explode relative to incomes (a distortion avoided because of Pennsylvania’s generally more liberal land use regulations). The American Dream – at least for those who are aspiring to achieve it – has shifted from New York, New Jersey and Maryland to Pennsylvania. This is evident from the housing construction on the west bank of the Delaware River and just over the Maryland line in York, Adams and Franklin counties.

Florida: A Changing Story: Flyover Country’s gains are impressive. Florida has attracted the largest number of residents from other states, at 1,250,000 since 2000. This amounts to a 7.6 percent increase compared to the state’s 2000 population. However, things are changing. As the state’s housing became unaffordable, domestic migration dropped and then stopped. By 2007, domestic migration fell more than 80 percent from average of earlier years. Then, Florida slipped into a loss of 9,000 domestic migrants in 2008.

Southern Gains: The rest of the South generally avoided the worst of the housing bubble. Texas has added 700,000 domestic migrants since 2000. The state displaced Florida as the leading destination for domestic migrants and has held that position since 2006. North Carolina has added 580,000 domestic migrants; Georgia added 525,000, South Carolina 270,000 and Tennessee 240,000. Even Arkansas and Alabama, although held in low esteem on the coasts, gained more domestic migrants than any state in the Northeast.

Escaping from California: Nevada has been a big draw for domestic migration, adding 365,000 new residents. This is 18.3 percent of its 2000 population, the highest rate in the nation. Arizona added 700,000, or 13.7 percent of its population. Much of this growth has been driven by Californians fleeing out of control housing prices, though their own more recently developing bubbles have probably contributed to somewhat reduced domestic migration gains In recent years.

Basket Cases in Flyover Country: However, not all is well in Flyover Country. Michigan lost 109,000 residents to other states in 2008 alone, for the deepest percentage loss in the nation (1.1 percent). Since 2000, Michigan experienced a 4.7 percent domestic migration loss, equal to the decline in Massachusetts. Further, based upon current rates, Michigan next year will probably be the first state to ever drop from above to below 10,000,000 residents. Illinois and Ohio have also suffered substantial domestic migration losses, at 4.6 percent and 3.0 percent respectively.

Where from Here? It is, of course, impossible to tell whether these trends will continue. Domestic migration could fall even more precipitously if economic times continue to worsen.

We cannot predict whether seemingly unlikely trends, such as net in-migration to South Dakota and West Virginia, will continue in the longer run. Will Florida’s losses continue or intensify, or will it resume its position as a magnet for residents of other states? Has the magnet of California truly lost its attraction? Will the improving trends in the Midwest begin to make up for half a century of migration losses? Only time will tell.

Resource: State Population & Migration: 2000-2008 (http://www.demographia.com/db-statemigra2008.pdf)

Wendell Cox is a Visiting Professor, Conservatoire National des Arts et Metiers, Paris. He was born in Los Angeles and was appointed to three terms on the Los Angeles County Transportation Commission by Mayor Tom Bradley. He is the author of “War on the Dream: How Anti-Sprawl Policy Threatens the Quality of Life.



















Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

These are some great tools

These are some great tools that i definitely use for SEO work. This is a great list to use in the future..
balo du lịch

Thanks for sharing the

Thanks for sharing the post.. parents are worlds best person in each lives of individual..they need or must succeed to sustain needs of the family.
girlfriendactivationsystemreviews

Thanks for providing recent

Thanks for providing recent updates regarding the concern, I look forward to read more.
isolatie vloer PUR

Absolutely fantastic

Absolutely fantastic posting! Lots of useful information and inspiration, both of which we all need!Relay appreciate your work.

windows 8 activator

mevabe

he thong sieu thi mevabe cung cap mat hang cho me va be , sua hop bot Dumex chinh hang, cac loai sua tuoi vinamilk 100% nguyen chat, sua Nestle cho tre em tai sieu thi sua bot lon nhat viet nam , ban co the xem them cac san pham sua gia tot nhat hien nay , cung voi Bao moi choi game iwin online tren mobile

Thank you very much for the

Thank you very much for the sharing! COOL..
http://www.slideshare.net

Hi there, just became alert

Hi there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it’s really informative. I am gonna watch out for brussels. I’ll be grateful if you continue this in future. Numerous people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers! www.prana.be

Well extremely thanks for

Well extremely thanks for your researched posting! I really enjoyed reading it, you'll be an excellent author.I appreciate you effort.

Thanking You

http://www.raginiroy.com/

Manchester

Well extremely thanks for your researched posting! I really enjoyed reading it, you'll be an excellent author.I appreciate you effort.

Thanking You
http://www.sheetsortho.com/

Sober Home

SCRC the best center for sober living. Customers who really needs sobriety are welcomed every time.
Sober Home

New You are able to has

New You are able to has missing citizens at a amount going above that of any other condition or the Region of Mexico. Not even the dangerous gusts of wind of Hurricane katrina anniversary passes and Rita, the malfeasance of the Military Corps of Technicians or even mis-governance – from California to Baton Vermeil .
kids game equipment

New York’s net domestic

New York’s net domestic migration loss is equal to 8.1 percent of its 2000 population, compared to Louisiana’s 7.1 percent loss. New York has even outdone that perpetual exporter of residents, the District of Columbia, which lost a mere 7.6 percent through domestic migration.
Fastest Motorcycle

House moving Sydney

Well really thanks for your researched posting! I actually enjoyed reading it, you will be a great author.I appreciate you effort.
House moving Sydney

our journal article is incredibly

Very expeditiously written info. it'll be valuable to anybody United Nations agency uses it, in conjunction with myself. Sustain the great work for positive. http://www.shushmanchester.co.uk

This is my first time i

Its not only USA but also in UK. I understand what do you mean by fly-over country. CANADA is another example. I think it is not a bad news. Their number of citizen is not so big. They are getting manpower which they don't need financially.......:P rushessay reviews is a valuable service.

Interesting blog

Yet things have modified materially, and for the most part for the higher. though Pennsylvania continues to lose domestic migrants, the speed has been so much but elsewhere within the Northeast. http://www.delhitaxiservices.co.in

Excellent and decent post. I found this

joy to read, I came across this site ages ago but I’ve only just decided to stop back and have a read of your articles.

Raspberry Ketones review |Cambogia review
coffee extract reviews |coffee bean reviews

The article

I have been seeking information on this topic for the past few hours and found your post to be well written and has solid information. Thx.
what does garcinia cambogia extract do | what does green coffee bean do | raspberry ketone reviews

Still, despite the reduction

Still, despite the reduction from the most extreme bubble years, last year’s interstate migration numbers still exceeded those of 2001, 2002 and 2003 and nearly equaled 2004. Lost in the discussions of the decline has been the continuation of a seemingly inexorable secular trend: the continued migration to the “Flyover County” that many of the coastal urban elites tend to dismiss as insignificant and even unlivable. What residents of Elitia reject, millions are embracing.

SEO Services Company

Useful sharing

How things have changed. Early in the decade, the Golden State was suffering somewhat modest domestic migration losses. text spy

best post

capable of deploying, designing, building, optimizing, and operating technologies for a particular job role. mcitp mcts // mcse mcsd // mcsa mcpd

Yet things have changed

Yet things have changed materially, and largely for the better. Although Pennsylvania continues to lose domestic migrants, the rate has been far less than elsewhere in the Northeast. free cell phone spy software

More About Florida

For years, Florida boasted the statistic of 900 people a day moving into the state.

Because these were largely service workers and back-office operations of large corporations, the growth was in quantity, not quality. Now that the growth has stopped, Florida faces a great deal of pain to retool itself, or bide its time and hope it becomes attractive again.

Mr. Cox correctly identfies it as a "flyover state" because knowledge leaders tend to consider other states when placing their operations. They do consider Florida for their family vacations.

Richard Reep
Poolside Studios
Winter Park, FL

Florida is NOT flyover country

Florida is where New Yorkers (City people) fly to in the winter.

There is a reason that there is town/city just north of Orlando named Winter Park.

Dave Barnes
+1.303.744.9024
http://www.MarketingTactics.com

I think it is a little hard

I think it is a little hard to classify Florida as "flyover country". Still, there has been very strong migration to South and parts of the southwest. Jobs + low costs == a very attractive value proposition. Texas is cheap to live in and the state added 222K jobs year over year in November, astonishing in this economy.

The Midwest is a different story. Some metros have decent in-migration figures, but many are anemic to declining. Indianapolis led the pack last year with net domestic in-migration of 8,592, or 0.5% on just domestic in-migration alone. That's not Texas by any means, but for a metro of 1.7 million to be adding domestic migrants at an ~86K/decade run rate isn't bad.