Small Cities Are Becoming a New Engine Of Economic Growth

800px-Downtown_Glens_Falls_New_York_roundabout.jpg

The conventional wisdom is that the world’s largest cities are going to be the primary drivers of economic growth and innovation. Even slums, according to a fawning article in National Geographic, represent “examples of urban vitality, not blight.” In America, it is commonly maintained by pundits that “megaregions” anchored by dense urban cores will dominate the future.

Such conceits are, not surprisingly, popular among big city developers and the media in places like New York, which command the national debate by blaring the biggest horn. However, a less fevered analysis of recent trends suggests a very different reality: When it comes to growth, economic and demographic, opportunity increasingly is to be found in smaller, and often remote, places.

Read about how we selected the 2012 Best Cities for Job Growth

This year’s edition of Forbes’ Best Cities For Jobs survey, compiled with Pepperdine University’s Michael Shires, found that small and midsized metropolitan areas, with populations of 1 million or less, accounted for 27 of the 30 urban regions in the country that are adding jobs at the fastest rate. The three largest metropolitan statistical areas that made the top 30 — Austin, Houston and Salt Lake City — are themselves highly dispersed with sprawling employment sheds.

Rather than the products of “smart growth” and intense densification, almost all of the fastest-growing metropolitan areas — including larger ones like Silicon Valley and Raleigh — tend to be dominated by suburban-style, single-family homes and utterly dependent on the greatest scourge of the urbanist creed: the private car. But many of the smaller areas also punch above their weight in myriad ways, spanning a host of industries.

Among the 398 MSAs we ranked for the list, energy towns dominate the top of the table:  Odessa, Texas (100,000), took first place; followed by Midland, Texas (population: 111,000), in second place; Lafayette, La. (fourth, 114,000); Corpus Christi, Texas (sixth, 287,000); San Angelo, Texas (seventh, 92,000); Casper, Wyo. (10th, 54,000); and Bismarck, N.D. (21st, 61,000). These cities’ economies have expanded steadily over the last few years, beneficiaries of a great boom in fossil fuels that, unless derailed by regulators, will continue for the foreseeable future.

But some of the other best cities for jobs make their livings in different ways, such as No. 12 Glens Falls, N.Y., riding growth in business services and tourism; and No. 15 Columbia, Mo., which is primarily a college and government town. Several smaller communities have bounced back strongly with the recovery of manufacturing, including No. 3 Columbus Ind., No. 11 Williamsport, Pa., and No. 19 Holland-Grand Haven, Mich.

This shift in opportunity also parallels some compelling demographic trends. In the 1990s, the rate of population growth of areas over 1 million and those below was essentially similar. In contrast, in the subsequent decade, urban areas with fewer than a million people expanded by 15%, compared to barely 9% for larger urban areas, notes demographer Wendell Cox. In those 10 years, areas with fewer than a million people accounted for more than 60% of urban growth. Essentially more Americans are now moving to smaller regions than to larger ones.

We  see is a very different reality than that often promoted by big city boosters. Large, dense urban regions clearly possess some great advantages: hub airports, big labor markets, concentrations of hospitals, schools, cultural amenities and specific industrial expertise. Yet despite these advantages, they still lag in the job creation race to unheralded, smaller communities.

Why are the stronger smaller cities growing faster than most larger ones? The keys may lie in many mundane factors that are often too prosaic for urban theorists. They include things such as strong community institutions like churches and shorter commutes than can be had in New York, L.A., Boston or the Bay Area (except for those willing to pay sky-high prices to live in a box near downtown). Young families might be attracted to better schools in some areas — notably the Great Plains — and the access to natural amenities common in many of these smaller communities.

Perhaps another underappreciated factor is Americans’ overwhelming preference for a single-family home, particularly young families. A recent survey from the National Association of Realtors found that 80 percent preferred a detached, single-family home; only a small sliver, roughly 7 percent, wanted to live in a dense urban area “close to it all.” Some 87 percent expressed a strong desire for greater privacy, something that generally comes with lower-density housing.

This trend towards smaller communities — unthinkable among big city planners and urban land speculators — is likely to continue for several reasons. For one thing, new telecommunications technology serves to even the playing field for companies in smaller cities. You can now operate a sophisticated global business from Fargo, N.D., or Shreveport, La., in ways inconceivable a decade or two ago.

Another key element is the predilections of two key expanding demographic groups: boomers and their offspring, the millennials. Aging boomers are not, in large part, hankering for dense city life, as is often asserted. If anything, if they choose to move, they tend toward less dense and even rural areas. Young families and many better-educated workers also seem to be moving generally to less dense and affordable places.

Perhaps even more surprising, this tendency toward decentralization can be seen around the world: much of the new growth is in smaller cities, with India as a prime example. A recent McKinsey study found that “middle-weight” cities, many of them well under a million, have already started taking a larger percentage of the world’s urban growth.

McKinsey suggests that the notion that megacities will dominate the urban future constitutes “a common misconception.” Instead surging smaller cities will constitute well over half of the world’s urban growth, gaining ever more share from the megacities over time. This is particularly true in the U.S. which constitutes the epicenter for the new smaller city economy. Of the world’s 600 “middleweight” cities, the U.S. is home to 257. Together they generate 70% of U.S. GDP.

What does this mean for investors, companies and individuals in the coming decades? For one thing, Wall Street, which tends to obsess over a handful of high-cost, dense, urban markets, may seek out new opportunities in faster-growing smaller cities. Prices tend to be lower and competition for prime space less intense, and the demographic wind is at their backs. Companies looking to expand may find not only a welcome mat from the locals, but also an expanding workforce in these generally more affordable places.

Finally, particularly for the next generation, the shift to smaller cities provides a whole realm of new options for sinking roots, starting business or a family and owning a home. Smaller city life certainly does not appeal to everyone, or every business, but their growing dynamism provides a welcome option for people who want to get a leg up in the next decade.

Read about how we selected the 2012 Best Cities for Job Growth

This piece originally appeared in Forbes.

Joel Kotkin is executive editor of NewGeography.com and is a distinguished presidential fellow in urban futures at Chapman University, and contributing editor to the City Journal in New York. He is author of The City: A Global History. His newest book is The Next Hundred Million: America in 2050, released in February, 2010.

Photo: Glens Falls, NY



















Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Your website is really cool

Your website is really cool and this is a great inspiring article. BTL

karine losier metabolic cooking

The chemical reactions of metabolism are organized into metabolic pathways, in which one chemical is transformed through a series of steps into another chemical, by a sequence of enzymes. karine losier metabolic cooking

To tell the truth, I really

To tell the truth, I really like this post and want to share to everyone. Thank you very much for sharing this interesting post. alarm system fort myers

tavlor

Art149 is a new project run by a highly experienced team who have helped to create many online galleries in many countries in Europe. Experience comes from customers in Poland, France, Spain, Germany and Sweden, and we have now been able to create an additional user-friendly gallery. tavlor

hi...........

This is the ideal post for someone who desires to be familiar with this subject. You certainly place a new turn on a topic that’s been on paper about for years. well basically im a travel agent and we offers Cheap hajj Packages | Cheap flights To Harare. Fabulous material, your post is absolutely impact a read if somebody comes across it. I didn’t grasp that this subject was so vital. You undeniably place it in perception for me.

Columbus Ind

Several smaller communities have bounced back strongly with the recovery of manufacturing, including No. 3 Columbus Ind., No. 11 Williamsport, Pa., and No. 19 Holland-Grand Haven, energy efficient lighting solutions

SEO Package

Along with other New laptop notebooks is that it is extremely personalized SEO packages
manual social bookmarking
buy quality backlink
pr5 backlink

Buy Backlinks

Hurrah! Finally I got a website from where I be able to truly obtain helpful facts regarding my study and knowledge.
high pagerank backlinks
SEO packages
manual social bookmarking

I have never read such an

I have never read such an interesting post before. Hack Facebook Account Password. I really like this blog also. Highly recommend to everyone. Thank you. How to hack a Facebook account. If possible, I will share this post to everyone. How to hack someones Facebook account

Really rarely do I encounter

Really rarely do I encounter a blog that’s each educative and entertaining, and let me inform you, you will have hit the nail on the head. Hack into Someones Facebook Account. I’m impressed with this post. It’s absolutely incredible. Hack into Someones Facebook Account. This post is so great and useful info actually. I really enjoy it. Thanks for sharing a great article. I have read and shared to all my friends. Thank you again. How to hack Facebook account

I've been trying to check

I've been trying to check out NPR's site for this NYC tiny-apartment proposal and am not seeing it. Is anyone familiar with this report or idea? Please let me know; thank you!
chicago car services

Hack someones Facebook account

All the contents you mentioned in post is too good and can be very useful. I will keep it in mind, thanks for sharing the information keep updating, looking forward for more posts.Thanks Hack someones Facebook account

I read a article under the

I read a article under the same title some time ago, but this articles quality is much, much better. How you do this..
capture his heart and make him love you forever

Really rarely do I encounter

Really rarely do I encounter a blog that’s each educative and entertaining, and let me inform you, you will have hit the nail on the head. I’m impressed with this post. It’s absolutely incredible. This post is so great and useful info actually. I really enjoy it. Thanks for sharing a great article. I have read and shared to all my friends. Thank you again. How to hack Facebook account

This is very interesting

This is very interesting post actually. I really like what the author said. Thank you very much indeed. I have read and would like to share this post to everyone. Thanks. Hack a Facebook Account

Very awesome post actually.

Very awesome post actually. I have never read such interesting post before. Thanks for sharing very informative information. I really like this post. Highly recommend to everyone. I am also looking forward to the next post. Thank you. Hack Facebook Account Passwords

Hack a Facebook password

I found some interesting things and I will apply to the development of my blog. Thanks for sharing useful. Hack a Facebook password

All the contents you

All the contents you mentioned in post is too good and can be very useful. I will keep it in mind, thanks for sharing the information keep updating, looking forward for more posts.Thanks

When it comes to growth,

When it comes to growth, economic and demographic, opportunity increasingly is to be found in smaller, and often remote, places. http://www.everycode.co.uk/store/myprotein/

This is one of the great

This is one of the great post in this topic,essay and essay writing thanks you very much for your post! please keep the awsome post going! I will be back for more!
handyman phoenix

But many of the smaller

But many of the smaller areas also punch above their weight in myriad ways, spanning a host of industries. plumber nj

When it comes to growth,

When it comes to growth, economic and demographic, opportunity increasingly is to be found in smaller, and often remote, places. link

Graphic Design Brisbane

Thank you for another essential article. Where else could anyone get that kind of information in such a complete way of writing? I have a presentation incoming week, and I am on the lookout for such information.
Graphic Design Brisbane

I am glad that it turned out

I am glad that it turned out so well and I hope it will continue in the future because it is so worthwhile and meaningful to the community.
microsoft word resume template

When it comes to growth,

When it comes to growth, economic and demographic, opportunity increasingly is to be found in smaller, and often remote, places. buy facebook fans

Thanks for sharing nice

Thanks for sharing nice information with us. i like your post and all you share with us is uptodate and quite informative, i would like to bookmark the page so i can come here again to read you, as you have done a wonderful job.
general contractor Tracy CA

Austin, Houston and Salt

Austin, Houston and Salt Lake City — are themselves highly dispersed with sprawling employment sheds. plumber in newark nj

A very awesome blog post. We

A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work.
Free cell phone spy
clubmz reviews

Rugby shirts

The condo’s facilities provide full family entertainment needs for your family and loved ones. Indulge in a serene and tranquil lifestyle right in the heart of Sengkang and FernvaleRugby shirts

But many of the smaller

But many of the smaller areas also punch above their weight in myriad ways, spanning a host of industries. electrical contractors new jersey

An iPod, a phone, an

An iPod, a phone, an internet mobile communicator... these are NOT three separate devices! And we are calling it iPhone! Today Apple is going to reinvent the phone. And here it is.
VPN ins and outs

female mind mastery by kirsten price

Thanks for some other informative blog. The place else may just I get that kind of information written in such a perfect method? I have a mission that I'm just now operating on, and I've been at the glance out for such information. female mind mastery by kirsten price

Several smaller communities

Several smaller communities have bounced back strongly with the recovery of manufacturing, including No. 3 Columbus Ind., No. 11 Williamsport, Pa., and No. 19 Holland-Grand Haven, Mich. how to send a condolence

If you want a cookie-cutter

If you want a cookie-cutter house located outside the city in cookie cutter suburban shopping mall hell with a snarled morning commute- then sure- you can scoop up such a gem for 150k-200k.
mba application personal statement

I live in small town and I

I live in small town and I like it very much. I don't like big sities and I think the future per small towns.

platform shoes
high heels shoes
prom shoes girls
pink shoes
wine accessories
310 shoes

I see that it has a profound

I see that it has a profound effect on creating the lens through which people process the world. Here are some local implications. electrician nj

You may post on the quotes

You may post on the quotes for the blog. You could tell how it's brand new. Your blog thoughts will springboard your participates.http://www.lapdiy.com dc power jack with cable

Twin fountains Condo

Twin Fountains Condo Launching Soon
Twin Fountains

mattress memory foam

But many of the smaller areas also punch above their weight in myriad ways, spanning a host of industries. mattress memory foam

Passing and adding through

Passing and adding through worthy subject, i am sure that you focused all aspects with real experiences. It's nice that you worked well and gave good material over here. Chatrandom.com

I am researching this topic

I am researching this topic for use in a future business I am thinking about starting. Thank you for this information, it has been educational and helpful to me. Reedy Creek Mitigation Bank

Desirable addresses, decent

Desirable addresses, decent houses, and access to amenities are now the province of relatively few, who are serviced by those on the outside, commuting into town from less hip and trendy places.
writing a research paper

I found some interesting

I found some interesting things and I will apply to the development of my blog. Thanks for sharing useful. Fort Lauderdale Plumber

Nice post. We appreciate you

Nice post. We appreciate you for the right to share this post worth your time! I've been previously searching for stories such as this for the way a lot of time. Merely exactly thankful that we established your personal. Impatient for your thread.Florida CPA

Odessa, Texas

Nice study about World's best cities. Amazingly my favorite city Odessa, Texas is on first place, i wish if i have a business like
Luzerner Generalbau AG, I was going to prcahse half of Odessa not full as for that i have to be the Price of 10 countries.:)

This is one of the most

This is one of the most incredible blogs I’ve read in a very long time. The amount of information in here is stunning, like you practically wrote the book on the subject. text your ex back preview

SMall Cities

Why are small cities dangerous?
Singapore is a small city but it is also one of the safest city in the world. Well, I hope so...
However Singapore is a cramped city with many high rise developments. Mount vernon condo is one such development. Seldom you will come by a similar development like Ang Mo Kio Cluster House.

Its not makes any different

Its not makes any different that a city is small or big but it should be good looking to call a good city,to have fun share all best serials

Small City

Small cities are the most dangerous place to live.

small city

Hi,

Small is beautiful. Isn't it ?

Small City But Plenty Of Opportunities

Twin Fountains is one of it.
Twin Fountains