Who Should Immigration be Helping?


Recent revelations about the firing of American tech workers and their replacement by temporary visa holders reveal, in the starkest way, why many Americans are wary of the impact of untrammeled immigration. Workers in American companies have been removed from their jobs not because they could not perform them, but because their replacements, largely from India, are simply cheaper and, likely, more malleable.

The H-1B temporary visa program was purportedly designed to help tech firms hire specialized talent to fill needs not adequately addressed by the U.S. labor market. But what it has really become is a way to lay off workers for cheaper ones.

Silicon Valley’s Phony War

A looming shortage of domestic tech talent has long been a siren song played in Silicon Valley by grandees such as Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg. It is common to hear them claim the visa program must be expanded for them to compete.

Immigrant entrepreneurs and technical staff are hugely important, but the notion about “shortages” of IT workers is dicey at best. A 2013 report from the labor-aligned Economic Policy Institute found that the country is producing 50 percent more IT professionals each year than are being employed. EPI estimates “guest workers” now account for one-third to one-half of all new IT job holders, much of them through contracts with Infosys and Tata Consultancy Services, both based in India. These two firms, according to EPI, have cost over 12,000 U.S. workers their jobs this year alone.

Read the entire piece at The Orange County Register.

Joel Kotkin is executive editor of NewGeography.com and Roger Hobbs Distinguished Fellow in Urban Studies at Chapman University, and a member of the editorial board of the Orange County Register. He is also executive director of the Houston-based Center for Opportunity Urbanism. His newest book, The New Class Conflict is now available at Amazon and Telos Press. He is also author of The City: A Global History and The Next Hundred Million: America in 2050. He lives in Orange County, CA.

Photo by telwink

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I would gladly accept

I would gladly accept amnesty for the eleven million undocumented in return for an across-the-board moratorium (pause, time-out) on all further immigration until we can integrate and assimilate the 75 million or so first- and second-generation immigrants who are already here, the vast majority from societies and cultures with no, or very weak, democratic traditions.

In the meantime we should investigate whether emigration helps or hurts the development of the poor countries from which most immigrants come. This is a neglected dimension of the moral issue.

Of course it is also about American wages and working conditions, but the cultural argument I think is easier to make. The preservation of our liberal institutions is something no reasonable person can be against.