Michigration Revisited

Only a few months ago, I admonished Michigan for its hysteria about brain drain. Given the recent news coverage concerning the exodus from the recession-plagued state, you might expect I’m ready to eat some crow. On the contrary, I’m here to report that Michigan has learned nothing from its past mistakes.

Richard Herman, an advocate for increasing rates of immigration to the Rust Belt, posts on his blog the same critique I have aired about how Michigan addresses its talent crisis:

However, the current focus on "brain drain" as the source of the problem misses the real issue.

While no doubt the Midwest economy is causing college grads who might otherwise want to stay home to leave, in an ever more mobile society, moving out is a natural part of people's lives. Indeed, if you read the typical account of how the elite global knowledge worker lives, you often hear about people flitting from place to place to place chasing opportunity.

The real problem is not that too many people are leaving, but rather that too few are coming. It isn't an outflow problem, it's an inflow problem.

The former urban industrial powerhouses of the United States all suffer from the same malaise. Every city is fixated on its local labor pool, asking institutions of education to staff the “factory.” The great irony is that economic growth doesn’t happen without immigration or domestic in-migration. There is no story of a great metropolis that successfully barred its people from leaving.

The tortured metaphor for brain drain stems from private enterprise. But even in the arena of human resources, the concept of churn isn’t an anathema:

The purpose of this article is to open your mind about the silliness of measuring only aggregate turnover. I can think of no better indication of a so-called expert’s lack of true understanding of employee turnover than when I read an article or a book on retention and the author invariably expounds on the need to keep everyone.

The burgeoning narrative is that churn benefits both employee and employer. The same is true for resident and state. Fear of the outsider prevents all parties from making a rational choice and improving human welfare.

Michigan should embrace its out-migration and aggressively seek new residents. I further recommend any reference to “retention” be abolished from official policy. Where, and how many, graduates go is largely immaterial. Instead of Cool Cities to keep Michigan talent instate; what would it take to get the next generation of engineers from Colorado schools or Asia to move to the Rust Belt?

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Hey buddy,this is one of the

Hey buddy,this is one of the best posts that I’ve ever seen; you may include some more ideas in the same theme. I’m still waiting for some interesting thoughts from your side in your next post.

Funnel Kit Review
WP Simple Split Review
YouTube End Zone Review
Mobi Video Leads Review
InstaTheme Review
Video Skin Review
Keywords Jeet Review
Instant Domain Sniper
FB Objective Review
Pandora Profits Review

nice topic

Really good and helpful information. I see your at post.I am exciting see your post.I like this post
mũ bảo hộ lao động giá rẻ tại HCM
mũ bảo hộ lao động giá rẻ tại HCM
Kinh bao ho chong uv

Kính bảo hộ chống uv

Depictions of a sexual

Depictions of a sexual nature Thomas Kalita are older than civilization as depictions such as the venus figurines and rock art have existed since prehistoric times.[31] However the concept of pornography Svenskalotter as understood today did not exist until the Victorian era. For example the Svenska lotter French Impressionism painting by Édouard Manet titled Olympia was a nude Svenskalotter.com picture of a French courtesan, literally a "prostitute picture". It was controversial porn at the time.
Nineteenth-century porn legislation eventually outlawed the publication, retail, and Svenskalotter.com trafficking of certain writings and images regarded as pornographic and would order the destruction of shop and warehouse stock meant for sale; however, the private Svenska lotter possession of and viewing of (some forms of) pornographyThomas Kalita ,
Svenskalotter was not made an offence until recent times
Thomas Kalita
Svenskalotter
Svenska lotter
Svenskalotter.com
porn
Thomas Kalita
Svenskalotter
Svenska lotter
Svenskalotter.com
porn

Depictions of a sexual

Depictions of a sexual nature Thomas Kalita are older than civilization as depictions such as the venus figurines and rock art have existed since prehistoric times.[31] However the concept of pornography Svenskalotter as understood today did not exist until the Victorian era. For example the Svenska lotter French Impressionism painting by Édouard Manet titled Olympia was a nude Svenskalotter.com picture of a French courtesan, literally a "prostitute picture". It was controversial porn at the time.
Nineteenth-century porn legislation eventually outlawed the publication, retail, and Svenskalotter.com trafficking of certain writings and images regarded as pornographic and would order the destruction of shop and warehouse stock meant for sale; however, the private Svenska lotter possession of and viewing of (some forms of) pornographyThomas Kalita ,
Svenskalotter was not made an offence until recent times
Thomas Kalita
Svenskalotter
Svenska lotter
Svenskalotter.com
porn
Thomas Kalita
Svenskalotter
Svenska lotter
Svenskalotter.com
porn
Depictions of a sexual nature Thomas Kalita are older than civilization as depictions such as the venus figurines and rock art have existed since prehistoric times.[31] However the concept of pornography Svenskalotter as understood today did not exist until the Victorian era. For example the Svenska lotter French Impressionism painting by Édouard Manet titled Olympia was a nude Svenskalotter.com picture of a French courtesan, literally a "prostitute picture". It was controversial porn at the time.
Nineteenth-century porn legislation eventually outlawed the publication, retail, and Svenskalotter.com trafficking of certain writings and images regarded as pornographic and would order the destruction of shop and warehouse stock meant for sale; however, the private Svenska lotter possession of and viewing of (some forms of) pornographyThomas Kalita ,
Svenskalotter was not made an offence until recent times
Thomas Kalita
Svenskalotter
Svenska lotter
Svenskalotter.com
porn
Thomas Kalita
Svenskalotter
Svenska lotter
Svenskalotter.com
porn

yes

Many students fail in their subjects because of plagiarism charges. Academic paper writing is never easy and we understand why some students copy the works of others because they just can't finish their own papers. Research paper writing is one of the most difficult tasks out there.

If you can't deal with your paper anymore, do not commit plagiarism. Go to our website and see how we can help you with your paper writing problems. visit site

What a nice post. thanks for

What a nice post. thanks for sharing. kelly handbag

Brain Drain

What would it take to get the best to move to Michigan? It would take the presence of a large, progressive manufacturing based economy. That type of economic system supports all the engineers and high quality upper management people needed to make a state or country thrive. Unfortunately, too many people think that a country filled with highly motivated, highly educated entrepreneurs, engineers or health care providers is feasible. In that world, everyone just buys foreign product, marks it up and sells it to each other. They will need to make massive profits if that is what we end up with because the other 80% of the population will be on welfare due to not being qualified for the jobs left in the USA. A properly managed manufacturing based economy is the only one that can productively employ enough citizens to support the country.

I agree. We should choose a

I agree. We should choose a state that can give us a work and feed our family.
agriculture essay