The Texas Story Is Real


Texas Governor Rick Perry entered the Republican presidential nomination race bragging about the job creation record of Texas during his term as his primary pitch to a nation starved for jobs. This triggered a flurry of debate on whether or not Texas is really all Perry claims for it. But while there is certainly nuance in numbers, and Texas doesn't win on every single measure, on the whole it seems indisputable that Texas did very, very well during the 2000s.

This may or may not be the doing of Perry. Nor are the national struggles clearly the fault of Obama. The  man at the top always reaps the credit for the blame for what happens on his watch, but the realities of the modern economy are quite complex and there's only so much influence a governor or president has – and that usually comes with a lag. Nevertheless, the Texas story can't simply be discounted.

Let's take a look at the top level data. While reviewing, keep in mind that the data for the US as a whole actually includes Texas. If you stripped the Texas data out of the US total, the comparisons would generally get even better for the Lone Star State.


The root of the Texas story is in its massive population growth during the last decade. While historic growth champions like California stumbled, Texas powered ahead, adding 4.3 million new residents for a growth rate of 20.6% - double that of the 9.7% US average.


Despite challenging times at both the beginning and end of the decade, Texas actually managed to keep those people busy at work too.  While it started out the decade with an unemployment rate above the US average, by decade's end, with population growth and all, it was well below it:


One reason Texas was able to keep its unemployment rate under control is that it added jobs – nearly a million between 2000 and 2010 in a nation that lost jobs during that period.  The chart below, rendering the US and Texas on the same base, shows that the two moved closely in tandem during the first half of the decade, followed by an ever-widening gap in Texas' favor.

Gross Domestic Product

It's not enough, perhaps, to merely ask if there are more jobs. Are these jobs that are producing significant economic output, as measured by statistics like GDP?  Looking at the data, we see that Texas again outperformed.

This one, however, can mislead if looked at alone. With all that population and job growth, of course Texas' GDP would go up. When considering the average output, GDP per job or GDP per capita is a better measure. The latter is reported by the US government, and shows that Texas actually fell short on boosting this figure. Texas GDP per capita is slightly higher than the US average, but it fell during the decade from 104.7% of the US to 103.7%.

Personal Income

Another way to look at this is by examining personal income. As with GDP, the total values are highly correlated with population and job growth. The per capitas tell the story. In this case we see a mirror image of GDP, with Texas somewhat trailing the average, but growing faster than the nation as a whole, improving from 94.0% of the US average to 97.3%.

Interestingly, the portion of personal income attributable to earnings is higher in Texas than in the US, on both a percentage and per capita basis. Texas trails the US average because it lags in investment income and transfer payments, which have nothing to do with the quality of jobs.

Household Income

Household income gives an almost identical tale.  Texas is below average but caught up during the 90s, going from 95.1% of the US average to 96.1%


More directly, we can look at the wages being paid in Texas, which flipped from lower to higher than the US average during the 2000s, though tracking extremely closely the entire way:


Lastly, the poverty rate is higher in Texas than in the US as a whole – 17.2% vs. 14.3%, not a small difference. However, the gap actually narrowed between the two during the 2000s, as the chart below in the percentage point change in the poverty rate illustrates.


While every statistic isn't a winner for Texas, most of them are, notably on the jobs front. And if nothing else, it does not appear that Texas purchased job growth at the expense of job quality, at least not at the aggregate level.  There are certainly deeper places one might drill into and find areas of concern or underperformance, but that's true of everywhere.  And these top line statistics are commonly used to compare cities and states. Unless Texas critics are ready to retire these measures from their own arsenal, it seems clear that Texas is a winner.  The Texas story is real.

Aaron M. Renn is an independent writer on urban affairs based in the Midwest. His writings appear at The Urbanophile, where this piece originally appeared. Telestrian was used to analyze data and to create charts for this piece.

Photo from Governor Rick Perry's flickr photo stream.


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I found useful information

I found useful information on this topic as I will be working on a business project. Thank-you posting relative information and its currently becoming easier to comprehensive this project Amazon Berries.


The first Pan American Women's Baseball Championship (I Campeonato Panamericano del Béisbol Femenino) was played in Valencia, Venezuela from November 13–20, 2009. Teams that competed were Cuba, Venezuela, Puerto Rico, Colombia, Brazil, and the Dominican Republic. Source : Jual jus kulit manggis Harga obat pelangsing slimming capsule Obat stroke

Obat kanker rahim

President Obama said in a television interview Friday that those upset with the Ferguson grand jury decision should not use it as "an excuse for violence. Source Obat Kanker Rahim

Now and then I’ll stumble

Now and then I’ll stumble across a post like this and I’ll recall that there really are still interesting pages on the web. ^_^. Thanks.
respark the romance pdf

Despite the fact that I

Despite the fact that I found this specific post genuinely interesting, I couldn’t help but to ponder whether or not the statistics you used are accurate. That claim seems fairly odd to me. Any thoughts whether or not it’s actually a fact?
venus factor download

I am glad for commenting to

I am glad for commenting to let you understand what a awesome discovery our girl gained checking yuor web blog. She discovered such a lot of issues, including what it's like to possess an awesome helping mindset to have a number of people effortlessly gain knowledge of selected problematic topics.

Took me time to read all the

Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It's always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained! I'm sure you had fun writing this article. - Susu Kolostrum Murni

This is exactly what I was

This is exactly what I was looking for springbed murah. This info is very good for me. This site is awesome. My spouse and i constantly come across a new challenge & diverse in this article.

Thank you pertaining to

Thank you pertaining to giving this excellent content on your web-site. I discovered it on google. I may check back again if you publish extra articles.. - Hotel Semarang

Diabetes Diet Diabetes Mellitus Turkpod

This one though is just wonderful. My friend has dropped his consistently and he told me every time he thinks it's going to be broken - he ends up loving the bottle even more because it outlasts every clumsy and unobservant move of his. I kept buying this product for my kids becuase the smell was so wonderful. We should have bought these for the little ones, too.' (O.o) He takes concepts such as relativity, time, and quantum theory and simplifies them to a level that is more comprehendible to the average person.
I didn't even know what I was seeking to be quite honest. This is/was a great scanner for a great price. I do not print a lot, but I do print everyday. Stylish and functional. The tests are really fun. This product would have received a 5 ++ star rating but it is made in CHINA, hard to clean and impossible to dissemble.