Migration: Geographies In Conflict

iStock_000002798651XSmall.jpg

It's an interesting puzzle. The “cool cities”, the ones that are supposedly doing the best, the ones with the hottest downtowns, the biggest buzz, leading-edge new companies, smart shops, swank restaurants and hip hotels – the ones that are supposed to be magnets for talent – are often among those with the highest levels of net domestic outmigration. New York City, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Boston, Miami and Chicago – all were big losers in the 2000s. Seattle, Denver, and Minneapolis more or less broke even. Portland is the only proverbially cool city with a regional population over two million that gained any significant number of migrants.

Those who find this an occasion for a schadenfreude moment attribute it to tax and regulatory climates. Clearly, things like cost of doing business are clearly very important. And indeed this is often under-rated by cool city proponents. And other things equal, people do prefer low tax jurisdictions. Still, is this the only answer, or is there another explanation? Could it be that rather than high costs driving migration, both costs and migration are being driven by other underlying factors?

Perhaps the root problem is structural change in the economy in the age of globalization. As business became more globalized and more virtualized, this created demand for new types of financial products and producer services – notably in the law, accounting, consultancy, and marketing areas – to help businesses service and control their far flung networks. Unlike many activities, financial and producer services are subject to clustering economics, and have ended up concentrated in a relatively small number of cities around the world.

These so-called “global cities” serve as control nodes for various global networks and key production sites for these services, along with other specialized niches they long had. In effect, more distributed economic activities requires increasing centralization of select functions, particularly the most highly value-added functions. Yet these activities are not set in stone; for example, areas that were once centers for global business, like Cleveland or Detroit, are fading; others like Houston and Dallas are rising.

Yet unlike the Texas cities, which retain a strong middle-class and middle-echelon economy, many of the more elite, established urban centers – for example New York and London – increasingly create parallel economies and labor markets in those cities. These cities now generally contain two kinds of people and firms: those who are part of the global city functions and those who are not. Those who are engaged in global city functions operate in a world of very high value-added activities; specialized, niche skill markets; and rising demand conditions. Those skills are not readily acquired outside of global cities. Often, they are sub-specialized to particular places as different global cities specialize in different niches.

In many cases, these functions have not yet migrated to India or China or often even another global city. This tends to inflate salaries significantly for these specialized, niche skill jobs.

On the other hand, many people who once thrived in these cities have not benefited from these economic forces. They often are in occupations where labor arbitrage is feasible, and their jobs can either be off-shored, or readily transferred to lower cost locales in the US. This includes manufacturing work, but also important but less specialized white collar occupations like basic accounting, loan officers, corporate IT, and HR. In short, the routine side of the traditional monolithic corporate headquarters and services firm.

In effect, in these global cities, two economic geographies share the same physical geography – and those economic geographies are in conflict. One set requires catering to high skill, highly paid workers and firms where cost is a secondary concern. The other involves occupations and industries where cost is very much a concern. The occupants of these two geographies have very different public policy priorities. Which of them will win out?

In a global city, particularly a mature and expensive one, the elite geography wins. It is generating the most money, and with money comes power and influence. Additionally, the high wage workers in these industries are simply able to pay more for real estate and other items. Their mere paychecks are driving up costs in the city they live in. They are re-ordering the city in their own high income image, aided and abetted by a speculative financial fueled housing bubble.

The prestige of these industries burnishes the civic brand, making them attractive to civic boosters. What's more, leaders in global cities feel that these are their businesses of their future. For them the attractiveness of concentrating in areas where you think you can create a “wide moat” advantage makes sense.

This is why cities like Portland, Minneapolis, Denver, and Seattle haven't fared nearly so badly – they aren't really full metal global cities and thus, while not always cheap, have remained relatively affordable versus places like San Francisco and New York.

At the same time it is not easy for these more expensive cities to adopt a low tax, low cost approach. For many reasons, places like San Francisco, New York, and London will never, no matter what they do, be able to match Atlanta, Houston, or Dallas, or even Chicago in a war on costs. That would be a suicide mission. Their logical strategy is to follow the law of comparative advantage, and specialize where you have the best competitive position in the market, and that's global city functions.

Many other cities have followed this strategy, but with differing success. Fearing to end up like the next Michigan and Detroit pair, many states and cities have invested heavily to build up urban amenities to cater to the global city firms and their workers: transit systems, showplace public buildings, art and culture events, bike lanes, and beautification. Cost fell by the wayside as a concern, as did investments in priorities of the traditional middle class.

This explains why, for example, not only have taxes gone up, but things like schools and other basic services have declined so badly in places like California. Traditional primary and secondary education is not important to industries where California is betting its future. Silicon Valley, Hollywood, and biotech draw their workers from the best and brightest of the world. They source globally, not locally. Their labor force is largely educated elsewhere. Basic education and investments in poorer neighborhoods has no ROI for those industries. With the decline of high tech manufacturing in Silicon Valley, even previously critical institutions such as community colleges are no longer as needed.

The same goes for growth and sprawl. They are playing a game of quality over quantity. They specialize in elite urban areas and elite suburbs or exurbs. For example, San Francisco also has Marin, Palo Alto and Los Altos Hills. New York has, in addition to Manhattan, Greenwich and northern Westchester. The only thing they need size for is sheer scale in certain urban functions, and they already have it. Growth is unnecessary for them and only brings problems.

It also explains the highly pro-immigration stance of these cities, as a large service class is needed for globalization's new aristocrats. Immigrants are needed as low cost labor in the burgeoning restaurant and hotel business. In America's global cities immigrant housekeepers, landscapers, and nannies are common. They may not dress like His Lordship's butler, but that doesn't make them any less servants.

Lastly, it explains why we have seen the same polarizing class pattern so consistently despite broad geographic and socio-political differences between places like Los Angeles, Boston, and Chicago, to say nothing of overseas locales like London. A common global phenomenon probably has a common underlying cause.

The traditional middle class, feeling the squeeze, is simply moving to where its own kind is king and its own priorities are catered to. In a battle of conflicting economic geographies, the one with higher value added wins, displacing others in what Jane Jacobs termed the “self-destruction of diversity”. First, an attractive environment draws diverse uses, then one becomes economically dominant and, through superior purchasing power, displaces other uses over time. The story ends when that dominant economic activity exhausts itself – the true danger facing global cities, though fortunately they are generally not dependent on just one small niche. It's basic comparative advantage.

If you are just an average middle class guy, why live in one of those global cities anyway? Unless you have roots there that you value, take advantage of something you can't get anywhere else such as by having a passion for world class opera, or are one of globalization's courtiers – a hanger on like a high end chef, artist, or indie rocker, perhaps – why put up with the high cost and hassles? It makes no sense. You're better off living in suburban Cincinnati than suburban Chicago.

And frankly, the folks on the global city side prefer it if you leave anyway. Immigrants are unlikely to start trouble, but a middle class facing an economic squeeze and threat to its way of life might raise a ruckus. That won't happen if enough of them move to Dallas and rob the rest of critical mass and resulting political clout.

Many of those leaving are college educated, especially, when they get older, get married, and start having families. A relatively large number of these people could be replaced by a smaller number of elite bankers, biotech PhDs, and celebrity chefs. In that case, both “narratives” could hold simultaneously. One type of talent moves in, while a greater number of a different kind moves out. As with trade generally, this could even be viewed as a win-win in some regard.

Again, it is easy to blame the costs and public policy. Clearly there is room for improvement in governance such as reigning in out of control civil service pay and pensions in places like California and New York. But what is more pernicious is the rising income gap in America, and the likely outcomes it drives when a city acquires a small elite economic class with incomes that far outstrip the average, and lacks strong economic linkages to the rest of the city other than for personal services. It sets in motion economic logic that undermines the traditional middle class, which then starts leaving, exacerbating the gap.

For years we worried that a large, stable middle class with a permanent, largely minority underclass constituted an unjust order. As it turns out, the alternatives are sometimes worse. Ultimately some American cities have come to take on the cast of their third world brethren, a perhaps somewhat less extreme version of Mexico City or São Paulo, where vast wealth and glitter exist side by side with the favelas.

This explains why America's global cities often feel more kinship with their international peers than with many of the places in their own country. The global cities, which now enjoy something of a political ascendency, are also sundering the American commonwealth. Taking steps to prevent a further widening of the income gap may be the only way to save these cities' middle class – and maintain the solidarity of the country.

Aaron M. Renn is an independent writer on urban affairs based in the Midwest. His writings appear at The Urbanophile.



















Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

The content thus created

The content thus created must be organized and presented on your website in a logical way for SEO and also to help users find related content easily. SEO companies in Northern Ireland suggest promoting your content to increase its visibility across the internet by sharing it on social media platforms to attract links. how to get upvotes

They can tell you that they

They can tell you that they will repair and restore in the website to give a better outcome. They create sure that your viewers has no shocks on the items and solutions that you are providing. reddit upvotes

I found that site very

I found that site very usefull and this survey is very cirious, I ' ve never seen a blog that demand a survey for this actions, very curious...

only available online

Very interesting blog. Alot

Very interesting blog. Alot of blogs I see these days don't really provide anything that I'm interested in, but I'm most definately interested in this one. Just thought that I would post and let you know.
www.rebelmouse.com

Very useful post. This is my

Very useful post. This is my first time i visit here. I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. Really its great article. Keep it up.
best ways to arouse a man

I admit, I have not been on

I admit, I have not been on this web page in a long time... however it was another joy to see It is such an important topic and ignored by so many, even professionals. professionals. I thank you to help making people more aware of possible issues.
our review

Wonderful article, thanks

Wonderful article, thanks for putting this together! This is obviously one great post. Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here.
total money magnetism

Packers and Movers India

Thanks for post this helpful post - Please visit for More information about -
Packers and Movers in Hyderabad
Packers and Movers in Pune
Packers and Movers in Mumbai

top 6 packers and movers marathahalli

The info you have shared is wonderful and it is very much beneficial for people like me who are always looking to update themselves.packers and movers marathahalli bangalore

Packers and Movers India

Thanks for post this helpful post - Please visit for More information about -
Packers and Movers in Chennai
Packers and Movers in Delhi
Packers and Movers in Bangalore
Packers and Movers in Gurgaon

Robot

Please continue this great work and I look forward to more of your awesome blog posts.
TeaterDating

Robot

Just admiring your work and wondering how you managed this blog so well. It’s so remarkable that I can't afford to not go through this valuable information whenever I surf the internet!
http://www.rebelmouse.com

Packers and Movers India

Thanks for Nice and Informative Post. This article is really contains lot more information about This Topic. -
Packers and Movers in Noida
Packers and Movers in Thane
Packers and Movers in Navi Mumbai
Packers and Movers in Ghaziabad
Packers and Movers in Faridabad

It proved to be Very helpful

It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commentators here!
ebook download

Thanks for the nice blog. It

Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog. Thank you for sharing with us,I too always learn something new from your post.

wholesale shorts marketplace

Awesome and interesting

Awesome and interesting article. Great things you've always shared with us. Thanks. Just continue composing this kind of post.
penguin method samantha sanderson program review

nice post, keep up with this

nice post, keep up with this interesting work. It really is good to know that this topic is being covered also on this web site so cheers for taking time to discuss this!
http://sgdatingweb.com/gfas-review-how-the-girlfriend-activation-system-attracts-women

I am happy to find your

I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. Thank you for the post.
affiliate marketing

Thanks For sharing this

Thanks For sharing this Superb article.I use this Article to show my assignment in college.it is useful For me Great Work.
hampton bay fans

Very good points you wrote

Very good points you wrote here..Great stuff...I think you've made some truly interesting points.Keep up the good work.
Amasuite Review

Most of the time I don’t

Most of the time I don’t make comments on websites, but I'd like to say that this article really forced me to do so. Really nice post!
Headlinr Review

Really a great addition. I

Really a great addition. I have read this marvelous post. Thanks for sharing information about it. I really like that. Thanks so lot for your convene.
Video Marketing Blaster Pro

Interesting post. I Have

Interesting post. I Have Been wondering about this issue, so thanks for posting. Pretty cool post.It 's really very nice and Useful post.Thanks
http://www.aliciapennington.net/

I am happy to find this post

I am happy to find this post very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I always prefer to read the quality content and this thing I found in you post. Thanks for sharing.
affiliate marketing

I would like to thank you

I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. Thanks...
Simple Traffic Solutions

I have a hard time

I have a hard time describing my thoughts on content, but I really felt I should here. Your article is really great. I like the way you wrote this information.
video marketing strategies

I admire this article for

I admire this article for the well-researched content and excellent wording. I got so involved in this material that I couldn’t stop reading. I am impressed with your work and skill. Thank you so much.
bv cure book

Nice post! This is a very

Nice post! This is a very nice blog that I will definitively come back to more times this year! Thanks for informative post.
Build My List Review

I am very much pleased with

I am very much pleased with the contents you have mentioned. I wanted to thank you for this great article.
Tube Live Profits Review

Very interesting blog. Alot

Very interesting blog. Alot of blogs I see these days don't really provide anything that I'm interested in, but I'm most definately interested in this one. Just thought that I would post and let you know.
voyance par telephone

This is a great article

This is a great article thanks for sharing this informative information. I will visit your blog regularly for some latest post. I will visit your blog regularly for Some latest post.
voyance gratuite

Robot

Nice blog and absolutely outstanding. You can do something much better but i still say this perfect.Keep trying for the best.
https://rebelmouse.com/penguinmethodreviews/

I have read your article, it

I have read your article, it is very informative and helpful for me.I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles. Thanks for posting it..
vitamin c serum 20

The post is written in very

The post is written in very a good manner and it contains many useful information for me.
steps to approach a beautiful girl

Thank you again for all the

Thank you again for all the knowledge you distribute,Good post. I was very interested in the article, it's quite inspiring I should admit. I like visiting you site since I always come across interesting articles like this one.Great Job, I greatly appreciate that.Do Keep sharing! Regards,
how to keep genital herpes at bay

very interesting post.this

very interesting post.this is my first time visit here.i found so mmany interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion..thanks for the post!
wie Sie die pdf kaufen

The company can white breach

The company can white breach search_engine marketing are mostly in accordance with the material on all technique and breach the circumstances with the important search_engines like google. Black Hat seo company will get know-how mainly and regularly are not able to adhere to the circumstances of service. www.triviacrackhack.net

This is just the information

This is just the information I am finding everywhere. Thanks for your blog, I just subscribe your blog. This is a nice blog..
Digital Product Machine 2.0

Wow i can say that this is

Wow i can say that this is another great article as expected of this blog.Bookmarked this site..

textyourexbackmichaelfiore

This is a great post. I like

This is a great post. I like this topic.This site has lots of advantage.I found many interesting things from this site. It helps me in many ways.Thanks for posting this again.
www.atonemententertainment.com

This is a great inspiring

This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information...
newest posts

These are some great tools

These are some great tools that i definitely use for SEO work. This is a great list to use in the future..
how to make a hot girl like an ugly guy

Thanks for writing such a

Thanks for writing such a good article, I stumbled onto your blog and read a few post. I like your style of writing...
Ai wei wei

This blog is so nice to me.

This blog is so nice to me. I will keep on coming here again and again. Visit my link as well..
www.keyc.com/

I found that site very

I found that site very usefull and this survey is very cirious, I ' ve never seen a blog that demand a survey for this actions, very curious...
where to buy girlfriend activation

Thanks for the valuable

Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here...
at home method

Wonderful illustrated

Wonderful illustrated information. I thank you about that. No doubt it will be very useful for my future projects. Would like to see some other posts on the same subject!
text your ex back review

Wow, cool post. I’d like

Wow, cool post. I’d like to write like this too – taking time and real hard work to make a great article… but I put things off too much and never seem to get started. Thanks though.
latest mobiles

Nice to be visiting your

Nice to be visiting your blog again, it has been months for me. Well this article that i've been waited for so long. I need this article to complete my assignment in the college, and it has same topic with your article. Thanks, great share.
über mich

Nice to read your article! I

Nice to read your article! I am looking forward to sharing your adventures and experiences.
https://rebelmouse.com/ultimateherpesprotocolreviews

Nice to be visiting your

Nice to be visiting your blog again, it has been months for me. Well this article that i've been waited for so long. I need this article to complete my assignment in the college, and it has same topic with your article. Thanks, great share.
am i too ugly to get a girlfriend

Excellent information on

Excellent information on your blog, thank you for taking the time to share with us. Amazing insight you have on this, it's nice to find a website that details so much information about different artists.
Edward Bass Producer

Thanks you very much for

Thanks you very much for sharing these links. Will definitely check this out..

text your ex back mike fiore program reviews

This is something I was

This is something I was looking from so long, but every time I ended up struggling with useless information.
Diabetes Deactivated Program Review

Thanks for the blog loaded

Thanks for the blog loaded with so many information. Stopping by your blog helped me to get what I was looking for.
Publicaciones más recientes

The Bodyweight Flow review

The Bodyweight Flow review shows it includes three different calendars labeled beginner, intermediate, and advanced that help organize monthly workouts with the exercises.

The Bodyweight Flow review

The Bodyweight Flow review

The Bodyweight Flow review shows it includes three different calendars labeled beginner, intermediate, and advanced that help organize monthly workouts with the exercises.

https://www.facebook.com/pages/The-Bodyweight-Flow-Review-Program-Pdf-Guide-Program-Book-Download/668921066569769

Bodyweight Flow is a

Bodyweight Flow is a completely new fat and weight loss program developed by Tyler Bramlett,
a weight loss coach in California. Tyler, popularly known as Garage Warrior.

Bodyweight Flow Review
https://vimeo.com/123161316

This is something I was

This is something I was looking from so long, but every time I ended up struggling with useless information.
Specforce Alpha Review

I wanted to thank you for

I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.
girlfriend activation system worth it

Positive site, where did u

Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting? I'm pleased I discovered it though, ill be checking back soon to find out what additional posts you include.
girlfriend activation system v2 review

Your writer's bio must only

Your writer's bio must only contain one weblink. When your initial locations of content have already been accepted and published, you may be more bold in your link-building techniques. http://communicationsbox.postbit.com/

It is a great website.. The

It is a great website.. The Design looks very good.. Keep working like that!.
reviews on the girlfriend activation system

his is my first time i visit

his is my first time i visit here. I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog, especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the leisure here! Keep up the excellent work.
Luxury Wood Products

You have raised an important

You have raised an important issue..Thanks for sharing..I would like to read more current affairs from this blog..keep posting.. http://phexavid.com

Hey – great blog, just

Hey – great blog, just looking around some blogs, seems a really nice platform you are using. I’m currently using WordPress for a few of my blogs but looking to change one of them over to a platform similar to yours as a trial run. Anything in particular you would recommend about it?
http://medicalmarijuanacorner.com/

Robot

Your music is amazing. You have some very talented artists. I wish you the best of success.
youtube.com/

Robot

Thank you for some other informative website. The place else may just I get that kind of information written in such a perfect method? I have a venture that I am simply now running on, and I’ve been at the glance out for such info.
https://rebelmouse.com/

Robot

This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post.
rebelmouse.com

I definitely enjoying every

I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work.
original artwork

Robot

Interesting topic for a blog. I have been searching the Internet for fun and came upon your website. Fabulous post. Thanks a ton for sharing your knowledge! It is great to see that some people still put in an effort into managing their websites. I'll be sure to check back again real soon.
http://loveetcetc.com/

wow, great, I was

wow, great, I was wondering how to cure acne naturally. and found your site by google, learned a lot, now i’m a bit clear. I’ve bookmark your site and also add rss. keep us updated.
buy twitter followers

his is my first time i visit

his is my first time i visit here. I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog, especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the leisure here! Keep up the excellent work.
samsung galaxy s6 reviews

Took me time to read all the

Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It’s always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained!
capsiplex

Answergen BI is a simple

Answergen BI is a simple self-service BI device that offers natural view of your company in a dash panel with graphics to understand information easily, and promote company income. blog here

If you are a person with

If you are a person with problems (or know of someone who is), automated home technological innovation can create life so much easier. check this site out

It also brings your item

It also brings your item down to a more human level, rather than a large, anonymous organization. One Bottle Down

Great things you’ve always

Great things you’ve always shared with us. Just keep writing this kind of posts.The time which was wasted in traveling for tuition now it can be used for studies.Thanks
caravan luifel

I leave a response whenever

I leave a response whenever I especially enjoy a post on a site or if I have something to contribute to the discussion. It is caused by the sincerness displayed in the article I looked at. And after this post Queen Of Charms
http://clashresources.com

I really loved reading your

I really loved reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to undertand. Unlike additional blogs I have read which are really not tht good. I also found your posts very interesting. In fact after reading, I had to go show it to my friend and he ejoyed it as well!
http://www.ebookreviews.ning.com/pdf/girlfriend-activation-system-review

I just couldn't leave your

I just couldn't leave your website before telling you that I truly enjoyed the top quality info you present to your visitors? Will be back again frequently to check up on new posts.
https://www.rebelmouse.com/reviewsfatlossfactor/

It reveals how nicely you

It reveals how nicely you perceive this subject. Bookmarked this web page, will come back for extra articles. You, my pal, ROCK! I found simply the information I already searched all over the place and simply couldn't come across. What a perfect web-site.
how can i lose belly fat fast at home

it was a wonderful chance to

it was a wonderful chance to visit this kind of site and I am happy to know. thank you so much for giving us a chance to have this opportunity..
wet room gully

I would like to say that

I would like to say that this blog really convinced me to do it! Thanks, very good post.
www.polet.be

Everyone should take SEO

Everyone should take SEO organizations as it's as aspect of your accomplish to comprehend. affair website

I was curious if you ever

I was curious if you ever considered changing the page layout of your blog? Its very well written.
glamsmile.com

I am definitely enjoying

I am definitely enjoying your website. You definitely have some great insight and great stories.
get the girl code review

I really enjoyed reading

I really enjoyed reading this post, big fan. Keep up the good work andplease tell me when can you publish more articles or where can I read more on the subject?
my thoughts

I recently found many useful

I recently found many useful information in your website especially this blog page. Among the lots of comments on your articles. Thanks for sharing.
Look for Velvet Avia Here

I love what youve got to

I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of text for only having one or two pictures. Maybe you could space it out better?
compare electricity rates

Sea Horizon EC will be

Sea Horizon EC will be accessible via Pasir Ris MRT Station. Commuting to Changi Airport as well as Expo is therefore very convenient. It is also near to White Sands and Pasir Park.
Sea Horizon EC Location

The city with huge number of

The city with huge number of huge buildings, big companies , good restaurants and smart shops are always ranked the first priority and often people chose that place as residential areas .This is simply because of the availability of their needs .

raku pottery